47

DispatchBulletinCampaign

by The South Pacifican Government of Office of WA Legislation. . 2,318 reads.

SC Recommendation Dashboard: Vote FOR 'Commend Kelssek' | OWL

.

————
·

·
·
—— —— ——
·


'Commend Kelssek'
·
·
—..—
·

Background Information

Proposal title: 'Commend Kelssek'
Author: Drawkland
Purpose: To award Kelssek a badge of commendation for their immense contributions to RP (mainly in the field of sports) and The East Pacific, as well as their authorship of a number of historical and WA resolutions.

Links


Vote .For.
·

The Office's Analysis

A distinguished member of the NS sports community, Kelssek is nominated by the at-vote resolution "Commend Kelssek" to receive official recognition by the Security Council in the form of a shiny commendation badge. In addition to their impressive contributions to sports roleplaying, their historical involvement in the WA and its predecessor and work for The East Pacific, as convincingly presented by the proposal in a clear and structured manner, finally leave no doubt that the nominee is deserving of such. Thus, OWL recommends a vote FOR the at-vote resolution, "Commend Kelssek".

Supplementary Opinions
·
·
—FOR— | —AGAINST—
·

For

From TSP Citizens

Tepertopia is a Deputy Chair of the South Pacific and the Director of OWL.

Tepertopia wrote:I'm not familiar with the nominee, but the accomplishments laid out in the proposal seem really extensive and are enough to merit a commendation, I think. Of course the proposal could have expanded a bit more on some points, as others here have pointed out, but I won't oppose it just for that.

From the World

Ceni is a known participant in the NS Sports forum and is a General Assembly author. On the forum thread for Commend Kelssek, they wrote:

Ceni wrote:Full support. As a former Olympics host, I can personally attest that hosting one is OOCly is a massive undertaking. Hosting multiple... well, it's a blessing that Kelssek is still around in the community.

Electrum is another known participant in the NS Sports scene and has authored SC resolutions such as "Commend Audioslavia" and "Commend Valanora" for their sporting achievements. On the forum thread for Commend Kelssek, they wrote:

Electrum wrote:I wholeheartedly endorse this resolution. Kelssek is a well deserved candidate for commendation. Kelssek's been instrumental in advancing human rights in the World Assembly, with two of its resolutions, the 'Convention Against Genocide' and 'Refugee Protection', forming an integral part of WA/GA law. Hosting four Olympic games also shows an insane amount of dedication -- I can attest to how difficult this achievement is -- many dozens of hours over a short period of time goes into hosting one of these, let alone four of them.

Against

From TSP Citizens

HumanSanity is a legislator in The South Pacific and a SC author. On The South Pacific WA Voting Centre's RMB, they wrote:

HumanSanity wrote:The more I think about it, I just become more skeptical of this proposal. I think the nominee is deserving but the writing is haphazard in some parts and generally lacks narrative and structure. It falls more than almost any other resolution for the "time to list some things" flaw, as it essentially consists of a list of UN/GA resolutions, a list of sports hostings and sports victories, and then a very very sloppy laundry list of every position they ever held in TEP. At no point does it create narrative and the TEP section in particular is sloppy, as positions do not equate to contributions. I'm against with a "go back, fix the writing, and try again" theme

Qvait is a legislator of The South Pacific. On The South Pacific WA Voting Centre's RMB they wrote:

Qvait wrote:While the proposed resolution has a somewhat solid RP component to it, the list of positions the subject has served as part of The East Pacific with no mention of their particular relevance undercuts the strength of the proposal. The author could improve the proposal by elaborating on the relevance of the subject serving in these positions or omitting the section entirely.

From the World

Praeceps is a citizen in The North Pacific and the author (and co-author) of several Security Council resolutions. On The North Pacific's forums, they wrote:

Praeceps wrote:Against. While the RP part may be commendable, the list of contributions to TEP are incredibly unspecific—it is just a list of positions—and should either be removed or explained further. I doubt that the list of positions needs to be included to make the case that the nominee is commendable.



·

·
—Link—Link
·
·

RawReport